Transcript 0:00 You're listening to The Key Exchange, where real Ontario stories meet real estate. So our mission today is to do a real deep dive into the Toronto Regional Real Estate Boards data for November twenty twenty-five. 0:12 We're gonna go, you know, way past the headlines- Exactly... to give you that foundation for making confident, data-driven decisions, whether you're in the GTA or, uh, out in the Greater Golden Horseshoe. Right. 0:24 Because when the numbers show a definite cooling, you know, sales and prices are dropping compared to last year, you really need to understand the why behind it. Mm-hmm. And that's what we're here for. 0:35 We're gonna connect those bigger forces, like high interest rates and inflation, directly to what's happening in the local housing market. 0:43 To show you what the data is really saying about timing your next move, it doesn't matter if you're a buyer who's been hoping for a break or a seller who's trying to figure out how to price their home right now. Exactly. 0:52 I'll be focusing on that client strategy side of things. Yeah. You know, drawing on that mortgage industry background to see how people can navigate this. It's a lot like how Himani Sood guides her clients. 1:01 And I'll be focused more on unpacking the analytical side, the market trends, the tech, the numbers, that sort of precision-focused approach that reflects Sushil Mishra's way of thinking. 1:12 [laughs] So we're translating the raw data into, well, real world strategy for you. Okay, so let's unpack this. 1:19 We see the November numbers are cool, but to really get why so many buyers are, you know, on the sidelines, we have to rewind a bit. Right. 1:27 We need to look at the economic indicators from, say, October and September of twenty twenty-five. What were those, uh, major headwinds that were really hitting the market? 1:37 Well, the central theme, and there's really no disputing this, is the high cost of borrowing. It's just been sustained for so long, and it's absolutely crushing affordability. Especially in a place like the GTA. 1:46 Especially. I mean, if you look at inflation, the CPI year over year for September twenty twenty-five was two point three percent. And on its own, that's a pretty decent number. 1:55 It's getting close to the target, which, you know, should suggest some stability. But stable inflation doesn't mean you can get an affordable mortgage. That's the big disconnect, right? That's it exactly. 2:04 The cost of debt is still the biggest hurdle. So give us the concrete numbers. What were the rates that are causing all this pain? They're, uh, they're pretty brutal. 2:12 The Bank of Canada overnight rate in October twenty twenty-five, it stood firm at four point seven percent. Okay. And that pushed the prime rate up to six point four percent. 2:21 But for the average person looking to buy a home, the really painful number is the five-year mortgage rate. Oh, what was that? It hit a high average of six point zero nine percent in October. Six point o nine percent. 2:35 I mean, that's just a psychological wall for so many buyers. It is. People who've spent the last decade seeing rates in the, you know, two, maybe three percent range. It doesn't just bump up the monthly payment. 2:46 No, it completely changes the stress test. Exactly. It raises that bar so much higher. Precisely. Yeah. Because the stress test forces you to qualify at a rate that's two percent higher than what you're actually getting. 2:56 Yeah. So with rates at six point zero nine, you're suddenly trying to qualify at over eight percent. Wow. And TRRE basically confirmed this. 3:04 They said households are waiting for, and I'm quoting here, "lower borrowing costs and more positive economic news." So it's not a lack of want, it's a lack of ability. 3:14 It's a lack of ability to pass the hurdle, or maybe just being unwilling to lock in such a huge long-term payment at these rates. 3:20 What's so interesting to me here is the contrast between all that financial pressure and the job market. Mm. Normally you'd think, okay, a housing slowdown must mean people are losing their jobs. 3:30 But the Toronto employment growth year over year in September twenty twenty-five was... Well, it was incredibly strong. A massive eight point nine percent. Eight point nine. That's a huge signal. It is. 3:41 People are working. The economy is, you know, creating jobs. The underlying demand for housing is still there, and it's strong. But all that optimism is just being completely choked out by the high cost of debt. 3:52 So the overall economic health is pretty good, but the confidence you need to make a huge purchase, like a house, th-that's what's missing. Is that about right? That sums it up perfectly. 4:04 The job market is healthy, but the housing market needs certainty to unlock all that pent-up demand. 4:09 And, you know, the leadership at TRREB, they seem to think that if jobs stay strong, that will help consumer confidence as we head into twenty twenty-six. And the second rates even hint at dropping. 4:20 That demand is gonna come flooding back. Understanding that is everything for timing your next move. Okay, so that really sets the stage. Now let's look at the immediate impact. 4:29 If those high rates caused all this hesitation, just how significant was the cool down in November twenty twenty-five compared to the year before? Uh, it was significant, and it was pretty much across the board. 4:39 If we just look at the total TRREB market, the drop was really substantial. How substantial? Total sales fell by fifteen point eight percent year over year. Fifteen point eight. Yeah. I mean, think about that. 4:51 Almost one in six sales that happened last November just didn't happen this November. We went from almost six thousand sales down to just over five thousand. 5:00 A sixteen percent drop in activity is massive, and that has to put pressure on prices. What did that look like for the average selling price? 5:08 The average price dropped by six point four percent compared to November twenty twenty-four. That's a serious correction. It wiped out over seventy thousand dollars in average value in just one year. Mm. 5:18 It brought the overall average down from about one point one million to, uh, just under one point zero four million. That's the number that makes a seller really pause. 5:27 And it makes a buyer take a, maybe a cautious breath of relief. Cautious is the right word. But there's a key detail here, and it's often missed in the headlines. It's about inventory. 5:37 New listings also went down, but only by about four percent. Right. And when sales drop so much faster than new supply comes on... The overall inventory starts to pile up. It just shifts the whole dynamic. 5:48 That is the most critical takeaway for anyone thinking of buying right now. Because sales plunged nearly sixteen percent, while new listings only slowed by four, the total active listings shot up. 6:00 From what to what?From around 21,000 last year to almost 25,000 this November. So a 15% increase in the number of homes available. What does that actually mean for someone who's looking to buy in the next few months? 6:13 It means the market for buyers was genuinely well supplied. Yeah. It's a huge change from the bidding war chaos we all remember. A well-supplied market gives you leverage. 6:24 You can negotiate on price, sure, but more importantly, you can negotiate on conditions. Like getting an inspection or financing clause. Exactly. 6:33 Longer due diligence, firmer financing clauses, maybe even getting the seller to help with closing costs. The power has definitely shifted away from the seller and toward that cautious, well-qualified buyer. 6:45 That is such an essential piece of strategy. Now, uh, we've looked past the immediate advantage for a buyer. What does this inventory situation mean for the long term? 6:54 I mean, does this backlog solve the GTA's housing crisis? Not even close, and Kiarabi's leadership is really clear on this. This current buildup is temporary. It's purely driven by interest rates. 7:05 So what are they worried about? The CEO stressed the need for a sustained commitment to new construction to build up the future housing pipeline. 7:14 They're specifically worried about the gap between, you know, high-density condo apartments and traditional single-family homes. Missing mi- The missing middle, exactly. 7:22 Once this current inventory gets absorbed, which it will when rates eventually drop, that structural shortage is going to create renewed pressure. 7:31 So this current quiet period, it's really just a temporary window of opportunity. 7:36 So since the big story is high rates leading to more inventory, let's, uh, let's break down which property types and areas felt that squeeze the most because the impact was really different depending on what you're looking at. 7:48 It really was, and detached homes felt the most pain, at least in terms of sales volume. Because they need the biggest mortgages. Exactly. They're the most sensitive to rate hikes. 7:58 Sales for detached properties fell a pretty dramatic 21.8% year over year. A drop of more than a fifth. That's huge. And where did that leave the average price for a detached home? 8:07 Well, even with that huge drop in sales, the price decline was, you know, relatively contained. It dropped 4.8%, settling at about one point three four six million. 8:17 So people are still willing to pay a premium for the space. There are just fewer people who can. That's a perfect way to put it. The volume of transactions is what vanished. 8:26 Okay, now let's talk about that missing middle, the townhouses. They're supposed to bridge that affordability gap. How did they do? Townhouses actually saw the largest drop in average price. 8:37 They fell 9.0% year over year. That's the steepest price drop of any property type. Wow, 9%. Yeah, their average price fell just under the million-dollar mark to about $997,000. And sales were also down big by 16%. 8:52 Why would townhouses, which are usually so popular, see the biggest correction? This is where you have to think critically. 8:59 When rates are high, that buyer who could just afford the townhouse, they're suddenly pushed out. So they have to pivot back to a condo or just wait. Right. 9:07 Townhouses lose that core group of entry-level buyers, so they get squeezed from both sides. They're less liquid than detached homes and less affordable than condos in this kind of environment. 9:18 That's a really crucial insight. Okay, what about condos, the workhorse of the 416? Condo apartments saw an overall price drop of 7.4%, and sales were down almost 20%. 9:27 So they weren't far behind detached homes in the sales drop. But the really critical thing here is the price difference between regions. Let's break that down, the 416 core versus the 905 suburbs. 9:39 Okay, so in the 416, the city of Toronto, the average condo price was about $701,000. But if you go just outside that into the 905 suburbs, the average condo price was way lower. How much lower? It was $583,000. 9:53 That's a difference of about $118,000. And that gap is where value-seeking buyers are going, even with high rates. That really highlights that the GTA is not just one single market. Right. 10:03 And when we look at the overall average prices for all home types, the 905 area was actually slightly higher than the 416. It was. 10:09 The 905 average was about one point one million, while the 416 was closer to one point zero one five million. It just confirms that people are still hungry for space outside the core. 10:18 In places like Mississauga, Markham, Guelph. Brampton, Thorn, yeah. Buyers are trading commute time for space and what they see as better value, and that's the strategic insight. Sure. 10:28 If you're selling in the 905, you still have this underlying demand working for you. 10:32 All this data, I mean, a 6.09% mortgage rate, a 9% price drop for townhouses, surging inventory, it just shows how chaotic and frankly stressful the market feels right now. It does. 10:46 And this is where you have to move beyond just analyzing data and get into, you know, a robust, personalized strategy for clients. Agreed. 10:54 When we talk about navigating this, we're really talking about personalized risk mitigation. Yeah. You can't just Google the average price anymore. 11:00 You need someone who can translate that 6.09% rate into what it means for your specific situation. Right. 11:06 So for example, with these high borrowing costs, how would someone with a mortgage background, you know, like Himani Sood, strategically advise a client? Well, his strength as a client strategist is key here. 11:17 She can help a client understand that their focus has to shift away from just winning a bidding war. Now it's about structuring their mortgage to handle future risk. 11:24 So do you go with a variable rate hoping they drop or lock in a fixed rate for security? Exactly, those kinds of questions. 11:31 And based on testimonials, that kind of solid advice is what makes a really daunting process feel stress-free, especially for first-time buyers. That calm is just invaluable when the stakes are this high. 11:44 And on the other side of that, with inventory building up, buyers have more leverage, but that means negotiations get more complex. Mm. That's where that meticulous data-driven analysis becomes so important. 11:55 And that's where the analytical rigor, you know, like Sushil Mishra's focus on market trends and legal details, gives clients confidence. 12:02 When you can finally negotiate conditions again, you need to make sure every single clause is airtight. Right. Use that opportunity. You have to. Yeah. 12:10 One client even specifically praised his rigorous approach with lease agreements and complex rules. When you can finally afford to do your due diligence, you absolutely have to use it. 12:19 It really is that combination of deep analytical confidence and, you know, that human support that cuts through the anxiety. We're talking about helping families from Toronto all the way out to Guelph and Richmond Hill. 12:32 And, you know, speaking of the human elementYou can't overlook the role played by Catch the Key's chief entertainment officer. Ah, Max, the Golden Agent. You got it. 12:42 It's a subtle thing, but the sources capture it beautifully. The stress of real estate is so high, but Max brings this warmth and charm. I saw that testimonial. It said he was loved by the client's kids. Exactly. Yeah. 12:54 It just emphasizes that even in this massive financial journey, that connection, that personality, it matters. It really softens the edges of trying to qualify for a mortgage at nearly eight percent. 13:04 So to summarize our deep dive into the November twenty twenty-five data, we saw a very clear market cool down. It was driven almost entirely by high borrowing costs and the uncertainty that creates. Yep. 13:15 Despite strong job growth, the high rates were the roadblock. They pushed sales down and let inventory build up. Which gives buyers a temporary advantage right now. A well-supplied market, as you said. 13:26 But the long-term supply shortage, that remains TREB's main concern. The demand is just waiting, waiting for the financial confidence to come back. 13:34 So given that current inventory and the TREB CEO's call for more new construction, this leaves us with a final provocative question for you. 13:42 And the critical question isn't just when rates will drop, it's what kind of home will actually be available when that wave of pent-up demand returns. Mm. 13:50 Will builders have delivered the projects needed to bridge that gap between condos and detached homes? 13:56 Or will returning demand just swallow up the current inventory, leading us right back to intense competition in twenty twenty-six? Your strategy has to think about not just today's price, but tomorrow's scarcity. 14:07 That's the tension you need to navigate. 14:08 And if you are a buyer or seller who needs that kind of strategic insight in this complex market, you can reach Sushil at six four seven three hundred six seven one two or sushilmisra.ca, and Himani at six four seven eight two one six seven one two or catchthekey.ca. 14:24 Whenever you're ready to turn market data into your dream reality, Catch the Key is here to help you open the right doors.